Heartbreak, utter heartbreak for England. Having played the majority of their World Cup campaign in the shadows, Steve Borthwick’s side finally showed their hand in stunning and ruthless fashion, only to fall short in the cruellest of circumstances.
Once again it was the Springbok scrum that came to their saviour, with two penalties from the set-piece providing the platform for the world champions to score 10 points in the final 11 minutes to turn a game on its head that England had utterly dominated.
The first penalty led to a try by RG Snyman from a driving line-out maul, then, with just two minutes left, another huge shunt on the half-way line set up the opportunity for Handrè Pollard to land the match-winning kick that sets up a final against New Zealand next Saturday.
Remarkably it was the second game in succession that Pollard, who was not even in the original Springbok squad, having missed out on selection after picking up a calf injury in May, kicked his side to a single point victory
Devastated by the cruel twist to a game that England had gone into as firm underdogs, the England players cut devastated figures as their last attempt to set up a kick at the posts broke down.
Steve Borthwick’s side had threatened to pull out one of the greatest upsets in World Cup history, at least since France stunning New Zealand at Twickenham in the semi-final in 1999, seemingly surprising themselves as much as the rugby world by the manner in which they took the game by the throat.
When Owen Farrell, England’s captain, smashed over a stunning drop-goal midway through the second half to add to his four penalties, England had led by nine points and seemed on course for a fifth World Cup final appearance.
Up to that point England’s pack dominated their opponents, and the half-backs executed a precision kicking game, with Freddie Steward, Elliot Daly and Jonny May all excelling.
But in the end, they fell agonisingly short, with Springbok Ox Nché producing a monstrous scrummaging display as England’s front row struggled to contain their opponents’ power, conceding four penalties after Joe Marler and Dan Cole went off.
At least England know they did not die wondering. This was one of the great Test matches and the level of performance has finally injected this England side with some much-needed credibility and a reason for their supporters to believe that finally their side is heading in the right direction again under Borthwick.
Seven of the match-day 23 are under the age of 25, and although the squad is likely to evolve when the Six Nations gets underway, England can now look to the explosive players such as Ben Earl and George Martin, who were both magnificent in going toe-to-toe with the Springbok pack, while Freddie Steward was a titan in the back three.
Ultimately though the Springboks, as the greatest teams do, held their nerve, even when they were so rattled that fly-half Manie Libbok was removed from the action as early as the 30th minute.
England could not have hoped for a more clinical start. Indeed the first half was by a stretch the finest half produced by England of Borthwick’s tenure. Central to their performance was Farrell, who delivered the type of edgy performance reminiscent of his match winning display for the Lions in the second Test in Wellington in 2017.
There were moments where his temperature boiled over, his exchanges with referee Ben O’Keeffe on one occasion leading to a penalty to South Africa being marched 10 metres, culminating in three points by his opposite number Libbok.
Yet what Farrell brought was brilliant game management in the driving rain, along with the precision box-kicking by Alex Mitchell pounding the Springboks back three, allowing Elliot Daly and Jonny May the opportunity to win contestable kicks to give England dominance in territory and possession. England had led 12-6 from four Farrell penalties and appeared to be in complete control.
Jacques Nienaber, the Springboks head coach, to his bench to restore order, but not in the pre-planned manner of the deployment of the ‘bomb squad’. This was panic. Off came Reinach, off came Willemse, both within the first two minutes of the second half as their error-ridden display continued.
As the conditions deteriorated further, England’s lead looked more ominously for South Africa. At one point Jamie George saw his line-out throw slip out of his hands and fly into the air. Yet it was England who were relishing rolling their sleeves up as the rain became heavier, delivering the kind of aerial dominance that the Springboks normally bully opposition with.
The seminal moment came in the 52nd minute when Farrell fired over a drop-goal of brilliant precision and execution to critically give England a nine-point advantage.
England’s dominance was such that it looked like another march towards a comfortable victory and yet there was still another huge twist to come as from a penalty concession on the halfway, South Africa sprung into life from the line-out, with Fourie powering towards the line, before De Klerk feed Snyman to spin over the line. Suddenly from nowhere it was a two-point game.
England for the first time began to feel the pressure. Another huge scrum on the half-way line secured another penalty and Pollard landed it from just inside the England half. For the first time in the match, in the 78th minute, the world champions had snatched the lead.
South Africa’s exit from the restart gave England a line-out on the half-way. Once again the Stade de France was treated to a relentless finale, reminiscent of Ireland’s last stand against the All Blacks. And like Ireland, England could not find a way through.
Match details
Scoring sequence: 3-0 Farrell pen, 6-0 Farrell pen, 6-3 Libbok pen, 9-3 Farrell pen, 9-6 Pollard pen, 12-6 Farrell pen, 15-6 Farrell dg, 15-11 Snyman try, 15-13 Pollard con, 15-16 Pollard pen
England: F Steward; J May (G Ford, 78), J Marchant, M Tuilagi (O Lawrence, 73), E Daly; O Farrell, A Mitchell (D Care, 53); J Marler (E Genge, 53) , J George, D Cole (K Sinckler, 56), M Itoje, G Martin (O Chessum, 53), C Lawes, T Curry (B Vunipola, 69), B Earl.
Unused replacements: T Dan.
South Africa: D Willemse (W Le Roux 44); K Arendse, J Kriel, D de Allende, C Kolbe; M Libbok (H Pollard, 31), C Reinach (F de Klerk, 42); S Kitshoff (O Nche, 48), M Mbonambi, F Malherbe (V Koch, 56), E Etzebeth (RG Snyman, 46), F Mostert, S Kolisi (D Fourie, 51), P du Toit, D Vermeulen (K Smith, 51).
Have your say and join the conversation in the comments section.
England v South Africa: As it happened . . .
Live Reporting
Related Stories
Elation for South Africa; Heartbreak for England
Telegraph readers leave their verdict on the South Africa vs England semi-final
Tommy Gavin writes: “As a Kiwi, on the outside looking in, some of you English are a seriously negative on your team. No, England haven’t been a good team in recent times, and no it wasn’t the best rugby, but it was still a gritty performance against superior opposition in dreadful conditions.
“Tough luck. Now – go the All Blacks!”
Richard Coy writes: “First of all, congratulations to the Boks, but oh my word, it could have been so different if we had more than 2 props that could scrummage. Not to mention two absolutely crucial knock ons from Vunipola.
“Still immensely proud of the effort, it wasn’t quite the hammering some ABE’s were predicting.”
Tom Bambadil writes: “What a match, the last scrum penalty seemed harsh but the Boks were the better team in the second half, good luck in the final. Proud of the English lads tonight, well done to Borthwick and his team for turning us into a team who can compete again.”
Nik Middleton writes: “Well done England, you played your hearts out there, nothing to be ashamed about.”
Simon Pearson writes: “South Africa saved by their scrum. Not entirely sure what happened to England’s!”
Paul Hughes writes: “A side with a scrum put in, who are in total control of the ball should play it and not hold the ball in the scrum for the purpose of securing a penalty. This is a matter for Authorities though it is good to see some referees sometimes taking the initiative.
What did you make of the semi-final? Please leave your verdict in the comments section below.
England full-back Freddie Steward
Disappointment but proud at the same time. We were written off before today. That performance today shows how tight this group is and what we are capable of.
First half we put in a really solid performance. We were in the driving seat at half-time. But we lost a bit of dominance at the set piece, dropped a few ball and made a few errors.
There’s a lot of emotion from the boys, but we’ve got to use that for the next chance we get.
Some boys have probably had their last dance tonight, and they should be unbelievably proud of their effort.
Handre Pollard ‘s verdict
England head coach Steve Borthwick
Immense credit to South Africa and the way they played. They had to find a way back at the end to get a result.
From our point of view I thought the players were magnificent today.
Coming into tonight I thought we would win the game. As I stand here right now I think the players should be very proud of their performance.
Player ratings
Owen Farrell shines but Handre Pollard delivers off the bench.
READ THE FULL STORY HERE.
Also, remember to have your say on England and South Africa’s performances in the comments below!
Farrell on England’s performance: ‘I hope we made everyone back home proud’
We can go through th whole second half and pick out any moment [that turned the game]. My overriding feeling now is not about any moment, but about how proud I am of our group.
The sheer will at times today was outstanding, and I hope we made everyone back home proud too.
This is definitely the last World Cup for some people. Who know what’s to come next. One thing I do know is this team’s got a bright future
We’ve kind of been through it all from the warm-up games. Cards thrown at us left right and centre. It’s been a real roller-coaster. To show the pride and the passion that we did and to fight for each other. I’m unbelievably proud.
Farrell on Pollard’s kick
I’ve seen him do that a few times, so I was ready for anything. But he’s a top class kicker and that’s a clutch kick if ever I’ve seen one, so fair play to him.
South Africa captain Siya Kolisi
All the hard that we put it in came off. It was ugly today, It was really ugly, but that’s what champions are made of. I give all credit to England. They worked hard. Coach Steve and Owen pulled themselves together and showed who they are.
It was ugly today, but we found a way to fight back and get back into the game. Really proud of the fight that we showed.
England did so well in the kicking game. They outplayed us in that. Our discipline was awful in the first half.
I thought we fought back in the second half,. and we showed what we can do with the full 23.
‘England were the better team’
The kick that won it for South Africa
80 min ENG 15 SA 16
The clock is in the red. This will be the final charge for England. They are on half-way, playing narrow through the forwards. Vunipola hurtles forward on a carry, but the ball comes out forwards. Just as they did against France, the Boks win it at the death.
A scuffle immediately breaks out with emotions running high. The ball has already been kicked out by Pollard. Commiserations for England. They played with tremendous heart and led for all but the final minutes. In the end, it simply wasn’t enough.
England are out of the World Cup; South Africa march on to face the All Blacks next week.
The final score in Paris. England 15 – 16 South Africa.
79 min ENG 15 SA 16
South Africa are lurking at every breakdown arm wrestling England as they try to run it back.
78 min ENG 15 SA 16
De Klerk moves the ball slowly before exiting well to half-way. England now have one more opportunity from the line-out. They go all the way over the top. Feeding Farrell who is hammered, but the ball goes back to England.
77 min ENG 15 SA 16
Pollard lines up from the half-way line just to the right. He should make this, and he does! The Boks hero from the quarter-final hammer the ball through the sticks. With three minutes to play, England go behind for the firs time.
76 min ENG 15 SA 13
The scrum immediately moves sideways and South Africa have a penalty. Genge is penalised for dropping to his knee. George is unhappy, but Pollard points for the posts. Could the scrum-half do it for a second game in a row.
75 min ENG 15 SA 13
The scrum re-sets for a second time. The game is balanced on a knife edge as Swing Low reverberates around the Stade de France.
73 min ENG 15 SA 13
The scrum moves sideways, but England survive. After South Africa hang one high to Steward, he makes his first mistake of the game, kicking one straight up. When the ball comes down, England knock-on. This is a dangerous position to concede a scrum, especially with Handre Pollard’s boot. England cannot concede here.
73 min ENG 15 SA 13
Lawrence come into the England backline to replace Tuilagi. The Sale man has gone about his work doggedly all night, defending obstinately and carrying hard.
72 min ENG 15 SA 13
South Africa reprise their alpha-flex from the France game and call for the scrum. Tremendous pressure here on Kyle Sinckler.
71 min ENG 15 SA 13
The South African scrum has clawed them back into the game, swinging the momentum. England must regather themselves. Care launches his box-kick too far. and Pollard calls a mark. He drives it to Steward, who challenges in the air, palming it to Itoje. Afte a phase in-field, Farrell hangs it up, and Le Roux calls a late mark.
70 min ENG 15 SA 13
The ball is dropped by Mostert as he is lifted on the re-start, and it spills to Danny Care. The Boks to well to turn though and bundle the scrum-half into touch. Pollard clears down the throat of May in midfield.
TRY SOUTH AFRICA! 68 min ENG 15 SA 13
Vunipola comes on for a battered and bruised Tom Curry. England must withstand the line-out pressure here. South Africa shape to drive, but the Fourie breaks away, powering towards the line. As England back-track, de Klerk feeds Snyman on an outside arc, who uses all of his 20 stone to drive and spin to get the ball down.
Pollard adds the conversion. The semi-final is well and truly alive!
67 min ENG 15 SA 6
The rain lashes down as the two front rows pack down. George suggests to the referee that Nche is stepping to the left to get an angle on Sinckler, but the Boks win another penalty. It’s wide out to the right and on half-way, but Pollard can hit them from here. He decides against it though and kicks to touch deep inside the England 22. That’s a fantastic kick.
66 min ENG 15 SA 6
O’Keefe calls once on the maul and England hoist it high – the ball is caught well by the Boks. De Klerk then clears to Steward, and England have a protective shield of white shirts around him. Farrell launches to the skies, putting pressure on through Daly. The winger challenges Arendse, but it comes forwards off his arm. Another test for England’s scrum. This one is inside their own half, and therefore within kicking range should they concede a penalty.
64 min ENG 15 SA 6
England penalty! Mbonambi is furious. Kolbe tries to take on May brunt for brunt and comes off second best. May then gets on the ball with support and wins the penalty. It’s been an extraordinary physical effort. England still have just under a quarter of the game to go though.l
63 min ENG 15 SA 6
With this scrum pressure, O’Keefe may consider a yellow card soon. The Boks shorten the line-out, but again it’s too low from Mbonambi. England hoick a wild kick up-field which is caught by the Bok backline. Now they put it through the hands for more or less the first time.
Punchy call with about 17 minutes left but cannot see how South Africa are winning this. Their set-piece foundations are gone, they’ve lost the kicking battle, can’t catch a cold. The clock’s now against them a nine-point deficit feels like 19. The only saving grace is their scrum, where Ox Nche – who impressed off the bench last week – is getting right into Kyle Sinckler and winning penalties.
Sidenote: Farrell and new captain Bongi Mbonambi have been warned about water carriers coming onto the field, so Farrell just went over to the England bench to warn them.
62 min ENG 15 SA 6
South Africa’s scrum is just staring to get on top of England. Genge and Sinckler must dig in here. This time Sinckler is penalised for dropping his bind, and Pollard clears to just inside the England 10.
62 min ENG 15 SA 6
O’Keefe has a word with both teams about the water boys running on. Each side is desparate for a breather before the scrums, but it’s slowing the game down.
62 min ENG 15 SA 6
England disrupt with another high ball, but then are pounced on by South Africa defenders. Borthwick’s side retain it though, and Earl suddenly goes on the charge. He knocks on and Pollard hits a cross-fielder. The ref calls advantage over, and May takes a superb take above his head with Kolbe lurking. Genge then hurtles into the South African defence but knocks on. Springbok scrum.
61 min ENG 15 SA 6
This time Danny Care fronts up. South Africa try to exploit the blindside with Fourie offloading to Mbonambi, but care dives low to bundle the hooker into touch. England retain their own line-out, feeding Curry on the gallop.
59 min ENG 15 SA 6
Very tough call from O’Keefe. Sinckler sticks an early hip out, but he then drives through Nche. It looks like Nche may have forced him to bear in though. The referee blows up with the ball at Earl’s feet. South Africa clear to half-way.
59 min ENG 15 SA 6
If England can work this ball back, they have a golden opportunity. Up against them is the behemoth Ox Nche – whose life motto is salad doesn’t win scrums. That should give you a flavour of the man.
57 min ENG 15 SA 6
South Africa are at sixes and sevens. Owen Farrell is producing a kicking masterclass. This time he drives a low grubber behind Arendse, forcing him to back pedal. Under pressure from the rushing Daly, the ball bounces awkwardly for the winger and he knocks on. Farrell pumps the air, egging his team on. First scrum England with their revamped front row, right on the Boks five.
56 min ENG 15 SA 6
South Africa have emptied the bench. As South Africa play off the top, Ellis Genge this time puts in a thunderous tackle, ricocheting the Boks backwards. As South Arica hoist high, Steward is imperious in the air and claims it.
54 min ENG 15 SA 6
England continue to hurtle into South AFrica in attack, winning the physical condition. This time Chessum flies up into his Leicester team-mate Pollard and forces the mistake. England kick deep before the Boks return serve to Steward. It’s a tricky one that whirls around in the Paris night, but he catches well and calls the mark. On comes Sinckler for Dan Cole.
FARRELL DROP GOAL! 52 min ENG 15 SA 6
What a moment, and what a competitor! The England captain steps up from half-way, way out to the right, and laser beams an inch-perfect drop goal that sails through the posts. Breathtaking work from the skipper. England go beyond a converted try.
52 min ENG 12 SA 6
Daly is having one of his greatest England performances. He puts in another tremendous tackle, and England win it back.
51 min ENG 12 SA 6
The replacements make an immediate impact. They thunder through the scrum, brutally reaping the ball back. As the ball comes out, Pollard puts in a pin-point cross-field kick to Kolbe, who dribbles ahead into space. Le Roux is in behind with green grass ahead, but the ball wins the race and goes dead. That’s a sighter of the danger the SPringboks pose. England make changes.
50 min ENG 12 SA 6
South Africa empty the bench. Kolisi and Vermeulen join Kitshoff on the bench. Fourie comes on, as does Kwagga Smith. It’s only Vincent Koch still on the bench.
49 min ENG 12 SA 6
For rugby nauses, and I would like to think to amateur enthusiasts, this is an enthralling contest. But there has been a notable absence of any backline play so far. As South Africa swing it out for what I think iis the first time, the referee spots a knock-on. Back to the forwards! England have a scrum right-field around half-way.
48 min ENG 12 SA 6
Itoje disrupts Kolisi this time. It’s a knock-on, but he is winning the psychological battle so far. de Klerk puts up a frighteningly high kick, but Steward takes with aplomb. Marler then tells de Klerk to stop being daft off the ball and gives him a healthy shove. Tough love from the big prop.
47 min ENG 12 SA 6
The scrum re-sets a couple of times, and Ben O’Keefe summons both sides for a word. On the third attempt it holds firm. Farrell is asking how long. As O’Keefe calls use it, England collapse. They stayed in the fight just long enough. George Martin then hammers Snyman backwards and Itoje rips Kitshoff ruthlessly in the tackle. Mitchell errs though for more or less the first time, kicking straight out.
45 min ENG 12 SA 6
So much had been made of the battle between Etzebeth and Itoje in this game. South Africa have decided to play their hand early. But how significant could it be for England to keep their powder dry with Genge and Sinckler on the bench?
45 min ENG 12 SA 6
I’ve not seen that before. The ball slips clean out of George’s hand off the line-out and flies up straight into the air. He looks on mystified. George will have to settle his nerves quickly. Arendse then disrupts England with his kick chase, forcing the knock-on. South Africa scrum left-field.
44 min ENG 12 SA 6
The scrum sets solid before eventually caving. O’Keefe calls to use it though, and South Africa clear to the 22. It’s well struck, but not a particularly effective exit. The man-mountain RG Snyman comes on for Etzebeth. That’s a huge early call.
44 min ENG 12 SA 6
It’s England who cave to the pressure this time, as Jamie George’s throw angles not straight. Scrum South Africa. This first effort of the half should give us a good picture of what’s to come, and if any tactical changes have been made. Still no forward changes for the Boks.
42 min ENG 12 SA 6
de Klerk comes on for Reinach, is this planned or retribution for that poor kick. England launch one high into the air for Farrell, who does brilliantly to scoop the ball back. Dogged work form the England captain. Everyone is onside, but England keep their cool, and Farrell, off the next phase, dribbles a ball through to the corner, forcing Willemse to flap it into touch. Le Roux comes on for the Boks – that’s all their backline changes exhausted already.
41 min ENG 12 SA 6
England disrupt the line-out, but Kolisi sweeps up as the ball bounces up. It’s another poor throw from Mbonambi. Reinach follows this up with a poor kick which goes straight up. England hand it wide right for May to chase and flap back. The ball is loose and Marchant dives on it, looking up into the eyes of the oncoming South Africans like a cornered animal. He makes the wisest decision he can which is to not move at all, and the Boks are penalised for diving on him on the floor. England clear up the line.
40 min ENG 12 SA 6
South Africa kick-off through Pollard, hanging the ball high and deep right for Lawes again. He catches well and England resort to Mitchell who clears to touch. It’s just short of England’s 10.
South Africa out early
Bryan Habana assures viewers the Springboks have received the hairdryer treatment at half-time. They wait for England, eager to get proceedings back under-way.
Have your say on the first half
Are England winning the physical battle in the first half? Have the Boks made the right decision to take of Libbok? Have your say in the comments section!
Have South Africa’s selection calls back-fired?
Couple of those selection calls made by South Africa backfiring slightly, with Libbok getting the hook on 31 minutes. That’s not quite the 28 minutes which Luther Burrell once lasted for England against Australia under Eddie Jones, but it’s not far off. Should Pollard have started? Was he even fit enough to do so?
Bongi Mbonambi meanwhile has now had two lineouts throws go not straight, and the back-up option on the bench is Deon Fourie who, while a former hooker, is now very much a back-row.
England go into the break ahead
They play one phase in-field through Marler, but there is still 10 seconds left. Ben O’Keefe calls use it with the clock ticking down, but the scrum-half shows unbelievable sang-froid to run backwards from the base as the final seconds run out before kicking over his own dead ball line.
Half-time in Paris. As things stand, England are going through to a World Cup final. But all that could change over the next 40 minutes.
39 min ENG 12 SA 6
Farrell bisects the posts with a laser-beam boot, and England stretch their lead. Borthwick’s side need a clean exit here.
36 min ENG 9 SA 6
Willemse shows great skill, chasing and successfully taking his own kick, but he is bundled into touch by Mitchell. England show better disguise at the line-out, setting a maul for Mitchell to clear. The scrum-half evade a flying mitt from Etzebeth to float one high into the sky. May chases and is taken out as he goes to leap for the ball, milking a penalty. It’s another tight call, but one that plays in England’s favour. Farrell lines one up from 40 metres out, around the 15.
36 min ENG 9 SA 6
George converses with Cole about the line-out call, and in the end they decide to play it cute to Itoje at the front who pops back to his Saracens club-mate. George grubbers up the line for South Africa to clear, and England call the mark.
35 min ENG 9 SA 6
The scoreboard doesn’t really reflect how domina
…. to be continued
Read full article at the Original Source
Copyright for syndicated content belongs to the linked Source : The Telegraph – https://www.telegraph.co.uk/rugby-union/2023/10/21/england-v-south-africa-rugby-world-cup-semi-final-live/